/

Barriers to Adoption in Education: John Slattery and Wenqi Zhou

Kathryn Conrad / https://betterimagesofai.org / https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Barriers to Adoption in Education: John Slattery and Wenqi Zhou

Barriers to Adoption in Education: John Slattery and Wenqi Zhou

Barriers to Adoption in Education: John Slattery and Wenqi Zhou

Who Are We?
As an urban liberal arts university rooted in a Catholic Spiritan mission, Duquesne views technology through an inherently human-centric lens. Our mission is not merely to transfer knowledge, but to cultivate profound intellectual development, ethical leadership, and a commitment to serving marginalized communities.

The Core Barrier: Cognitive Deskilling
The primary barrier to procuring and integrating AI at our institution is the imminent risk of cognitive deskilling. That is, students rely on generative algorithms to bypass the intellectual struggle required for genuine learning. Mainstream AI products (like standard LLMs) are engineered entirely around a top-down, industry-driven push for productivity and efficiency. They are designed as answer engines that minimize user friction and instantly deliver polished final outputs. This may be desirable in the corporate sector, but it is a critical problem in education. The friction of wrestling with complex concepts is the learning process. Because

current products are designed to eliminate this friction, adopting them risks undermining the educational process.1 We foresee deep institutional resistance to adopting these tools alongside profound concerns over the degradation of student learning when these tools are proactively used. Higher education institutions do not know how to evaluate AI tools for pedagogical safety. There are no standardized frameworks to evaluate the cognitive impact of AI tools, and no movement from AI companies

themselves to pay attention to this troubling indicator. This includes standards of differentiating between tools designed as answer generators versus reasoning partners, transparent labeling of how models process and shape human reasoning, and evaluating the long-term impact of algorithmic reliance on young people’s independent critical thinking skills as well as their ethical decision-making capabilities.

Why This Barrier Matters
This educational barrier directly impacts American technological dominance and national security. A workforce habituated to cognitive deskilling is uniquely vulnerable to foreign attacks, including adversarial AI, deepfakes, and sophisticated disinformation campaigns. Acute critical thinking is the ultimate human firewall. If educational standards fail to protect this skill, we will weaken our domestic defense long-term against a wide range of operations from foreign adversaries. American technological dominance will also not be sustained if we hollow out our intellectual capital. If we allow cognitive deskilling to become the norm in education, we will begin producing generations of workers less skilled than the previous ones. Students need reliable training in critical thinking in order to become the innovators of tomorrow.

About

Mission

Team
FAQ

Stories

Coming Soon!

Research

Annual Report
Reports

Events


Sign Up for our Newsletter

600 Forbes Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15282

Site Policies | © 2026 Mosaic Storytelling Lab

About

Mission

Team
FAQ

Stories

Coming Soon!

Research

Annual Report
Reports

Events


Sign Up for our Newsletter

600 Forbes Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15282

Site Policies | © 2026 Mosaic Storytelling Lab

About

Mission

Team
FAQ

Stories

Coming Soon!

Research

Annual Report
Reports

Events


Sign Up for our Newsletter

(555) 555-5555
600 Forbes Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15282

Site Policies
© 2026 Mosaic Storytelling Lab